There is nothing as politically corrosive as hypocrisy, and Donald Trump is wallowing in it.
His White House is scrambling to test everyone in sight – often multiple times – to contain a Covid-19 outbreak involving at least two staff members and possibly many more.
At the same time, however, Trump is urging ordinary Americans to return to work without any way to know who around them might be contagious.
It’s not just hypocrisy – it’s Hunger-Games-level hypocrisy, with ample testing for the ruling class while the rest of us fight for scraps and are forcibly enlisted as “warriors” in a battle to restore the rich man’s economy.
Confronted with questions about this obvious double standard at a news conference on Monday afternoon, Trump unleashed his usual arsenal of confabulation, denying the underlying reality and attacking the media.
Most notably, he repeatedly insisted that any American who wants a test can get one – something that’s wildly untrue. “If somebody wants to be tested right now, they’ll be able to be tested,” he said.
Whether he was knowingly lying, or engaging in magical thinking, or clueless, or delusional, or projecting from his own experience — who knows? But it’s entirely possible that it’s all of those things at once. Trump genuinely doesn’t seem to understand the point of testing. “One person tested positive, surprisingly, because, the previous day, tested negative,” he said Monday. That echoed comments he made last week about a staffer who “tested very good for a long period of time, and then all of a sudden… she tested positive out of the blue.”
Do I need to say it? The whole point of testing is to identify people who have gone from negative to positive. (Stephen Colbert on Monday night nominated Trump’s statement in the category of “dumbest thing ever spoken by man.”)
Trump even went so far as to announce on Monday that every American worker could get tested every day “very soon.” If anyone had believed him, that would have been major news. That would be about 150 million tests a day. We’re doing about 300,000 a day right now.
Trump’s entire news conference was a farce, from his pronouncement that the country has “prevailed” over the pandemic (later he clarified that he meant “prevailed on testing”); to his child-like refusal to explain what he meant by “Obamagate” (“You know what the crime is,” he said, after being asked what the crime was); to his stomping off in a huff at the end.
When asked point-blank about his hypocrisy by a woman reporter, Trump lit into her:
Q — there does seem to be a double standard here, Mr. President, where members of your own staff can get tests frequently when they need it, but ordinary Americans cannot.
THE PRESIDENT: Yeah.
Q So when will the rest of America have the same access that members of your own White House have to testing?
THE PRESIDENT: And you know what? If we didn’t get the tests, if we did no tests in the White House, you’d be up complaining, “Why aren’t you getting tests for the White House?” See, we can’t win, because if we didn’t get the tests, you’d be up — I understand you very well, better than you understand yourself — and, frankly, if we didn’t get tests done, you’d be up complaining about the fact that we didn’t have the tests done.
Now that we’re doing so well on tests and so quick and so fast — five minutes, et cetera — and so accurate, you’re complaining that we’re getting too many tests. So, you can’t win.
The best-case scenario here for Trump is 1) to create so much confusion about what’s real that the public doesn’t really know what to think, and 2) for the media to drop this story line in order to chase the next one (ideally, “Obamagate”). This is a perfect example of what New York University journalism professor Jay Rosen calls “the manufacture of confusion.”
But this particular story line may defy Trump’s usual tactics, because the narrative is so simple, and the press smells blood.
‘Testing for me, but not for thee’
“Testing for me, but not for thee,” is how CNN anchor Jake Tapper put it on Monday afternoon.
Washington Post “Plum Line” blogger Greg Sargent on Monday called it “the sort of glaring double standard that’s catnip to political media: The White House is taking extensive steps to protect Trump and his top advisers with resources that are largely unavailable to the rest of us, in part due to his own dereliction.”
And that’s not all, Sargent wrote:
It’s also that this shatters the larger illusion Trump is trying to weave with his magical reality-bending powers — that the coronavirus has been so tamed by his stupendous leadership that it’s now safe to reopen the country, setting the stage for an equally spectacular Trump-marshaled comeback.
Stephen Collinson, writing on the CNN web site, posed this “essential question”:
If people around Trump are not protected from the virus in the most highly secured workplace in the country, how can it be safe for anyone else to go back to work?
It’s not, and Trump knows it. He’s worried that aides contracting the virus will undercut his message that the outbreak is fading, according to a person who spoke to him. He’s asked why his valets weren’t ordered to wear masks before this week, according to the person, even though that’s the example he himself has set. And Trump has told people he doesn’t want to be near anyone who hasn’t been tested, according to the person who spoke to the President, CNN’s Kevin Liptak reported.
In an article last week headlined “The sharp hypocrisy of the White House position on testing,” Washington Post reporter Philip Bump pointed out that everyone Trump interacted with during a visit to a mask factory in Arizona had been tested by the White House.
“This is a step beyond simply screening employees for symptoms such as coughing or fevers,” Bump observed. “This is an effort to create a safe, virus-free bubble around Trump and his team.”
Also in the Washington Post, reporter Amber Phillips wrote that the White House outbreak “raises the question: How can it be safe for the average American business without such testing capabilities or room to put such protocols in place reopen its doors? A majority of states have started at least a partial reopening, despite the fact that there isn’t nearly sufficient testing to monitor everyone who wants to get back to work.”
Political blogger Heather Digby Parton noted that right after Trump’s valet tested positive, Trump and Pence were immediately tested again:
How nice for them, right? In fact, that’s how we’d all like things to work but he doesn’t want any more testing because it makes him “look bad.”
Trump will not self-quarantine. He doesn’t need to. He can get tested any time he wants to. Nice for him. Too bad for everyone else.
(If you missed it, please read my column from last week: Trump blocks desperately needed national testing program, says tests make things “look bad”.)
Most damaging of all, perhaps, is that the late-night comedians are onto Trump as well. This is gold for them.
Here’s Stephen Colbert on Monday night:
After quoting White House economic adviser Kevin Hassett’s comment over the weekend that “It is scary to go to work,” Colbert said:
Really? You work in the most tested place in the world and you’re scared? Hey, I’ve got a spooky story for you: You’re driving on the highway late at night, when suddenly, a hideous old man rises up in your back seat and says, [Trump voice:] ‘You should go back to your job at the meat packing plant — Donny want burger.’
And here’s Seth Meyers:
The Trump administration understands the importance of testing to safely reopen the economy because they’re testing themselves, they just don’t care about testing you…
They just want to protect themselves while telling you that you need to be a ‘warrior’ and get back out there to get the economy going…
They’re looking out for themselves, not you. That’s why they’re testing themselves and stuffing bailout money into the pockets of big corporations and the wealthy…
The point is not that the president shouldn’t get tested; it’s that if he wants to force working people back into the economy prematurely in the middle of a deadly pandemic, he should make sure everyone else can get tested, too.
Even if they don’t get another shot at Trump soon, reporters can be counted on to keep peppering Press Secretary Kayleigh McEnany on the topic. They tried twice last week.
CNN’s Jim Acosta asked at the briefing on Wednesday : “Why shouldn’t all Americans who go back to work be able to get a test before they do to feel comfortable in their own work environment to be interacting with other individuals?”
And the Associated Press’s Zeke Miller asked on Friday: “Why should the average American, whose workplace doesn’t have access to these rapid tests, feel comfortable going to work if the White House isn’t even safe for people?
McEnany didn’t respond with anything of substance.
Hypocrisy is hardly new to Trump. So many of his campaign promises — to help lower-middle-class Americans and drain the swamp, for example — have been utterly hypocritical. But the reality in most cases is complicated. As a result, he has managed to sustain the illusion within his base that he is not, in fact, saying one thing and doing another.
Here, it’s not so complicated.
Tests for me but not for thee.
A note from Dan Froomkin:
I’ve written a lot about Trump’s response to the pandemic, and here is what has been clear all along: He has no real plan to restore the country to health other than to peddle false hope, predict a quick end, adopt fake deadlines and shift the blame to others. The most urgent need is to test, test, test, and either he doesn’t get it or he doesn’t want to know the results because they “look bad”. The media has blown its coverage of the federal response by letting political reporters lead instead of health reporters. Political reporters pay way too much attention to whatever Trump says, such that whatever it is makes headlines. They let Trump set the agenda instead of letting knowledgeable people do it. Political reporters also give Trump way too much credit for trying, which he is not. They cover up for his incoherence, ignorance, cluelessness, gaslighting, and yes, just plain stupidity. They generally fail to properly exploit their rare access to him by confronting him with facts and piercing his bubble. They remain complacent in the face of a massive death toll, instead of relentlessly demanding more forceful action.
Please consider supporting my work, which is dependent on donations and grants.